Western Legends: Fistful of Extras contains all stretch goals that were unlocked during the Kickstarter campaign for Western Legends that was held in January 2018. This expansion includes:
- 5 new characters: Belle Starr, Isom Dart, Allan Pinkerton, Buffalo Bill Cody, and Bat Masterson
- 20 new character goal cards (four for each new character)
- 20 new story cards
- 6 new player miniatures: Cowboy, Gentleman, Native American, Wyatt Earp, Calamity Jane, and Jesse James
- 3 new item cards: Work Horse, Holster, and Peacekeeper (six cards each)
- A cloth bag to hold your legendary tokens